Black and gold graphic that reads, “They just don’t have everything I’m looking for,” with the label “Filtering” from the Where Dating Gets Stuck series.

They Just Don’t Have Everything I’m Looking For

September 04, 2025•8 min read

They Just Don’t Have Everything I’m Looking For

Maybe you are meeting people.

That is not the problem.

The problem is that you keep thinking:

“They just don’t have everything I’m looking for.”

They are too far away.

Too short.

Too old.

Too young.

Not your usual type.

Wrong job.

Wrong hobbies.

No college degree.

Their profile does not excite you.

Something just feels a little off.

So you pass.

And sometimes, that is exactly what you should do.

But sometimes there is another question worth asking:

Am I filtering for what actually matters in a partnership, or am I filtering for the picture I already had in my head?

Filtering happens before you know very much

Filtering is the part of dating where you decide:

“Would I even consider this person?”

We all do it.

We have to.

You cannot seriously consider every single person you meet.

The problem is not that you have filters.

The question is whether your filters are helping you find a good partner or quietly removing people who may have been worth learning more about.

That is a very different question.

You have preferences, but not every preference should be a requirement

This is where things can get tricky.

There are things you truly need in a partner.

Then there are things you strongly prefer.

And then there are things that would simply be nice.

Those are not all the same.

For example, you may need someone who wants a committed partnership.

You may need someone whose values fit with yours.

You may need someone whose lifestyle works with the life you want to build.

Those things can matter a lot.

But maybe you prefer someone who is six feet tall.

Maybe you pictured someone with a certain career.

Maybe you always imagined being with someone who loves hiking as much as you do.

Maybe you prefer that they live within 15 minutes of your house.

Those preferences are not wrong.

But it helps to know which things are true partnership requirements and which things are part of your preferred package.

Because if every preference becomes a requirement, your dating pool can shrink very quickly.

A filter can unintentionally remove someone before you have any evidence

Here is an important distinction.

A filter decides who gets considered.

Screening happens after that.

Screening is where you begin learning:

Who are they?

How do they live?

What do they value?

How do they communicate?

What are they looking for?

How do they handle responsibility?

Do their words and behavior match?

Do they have what it takes to build the kind of partnership you want?

You cannot learn those things about someone you filtered out before the conversation even started.

That does not mean you should give everyone a chance.

It means some filters may be making decisions before you have enough useful information to make them.

Sometimes we confuse familiarity with compatibility

Most of us have an idea of who we think we would be attracted to.

We know our “type.”

We know what usually catches our attention.

That can be useful.

But your usual type is not automatically the same thing as a good partner for you.

Someone can look exactly right and be completely wrong for the life you want.

Someone else may not match the picture in your head and still have many of the qualities that actually matter in partnership.

That does not mean attraction does not matter.

It does.

You do not need to talk yourself into wanting someone you are not interested in.

But there can be a difference between:

“I’m not attracted to this person.”

and

“This person does not look like the kind of person I normally choose.”

Those are worth separating.

Small filters can stack up fast

One preference may not limit you very much.

But several together can.

Imagine your list looks something like this:

They need to be within three years of your age.

They need to live within 10 miles.

They need to be at least a certain height.

They need to have a certain level of education.

They need to have a certain type of job.

They need to share your favorite activities.

They need to look good in their dating profile.

They need to create immediate chemistry.

Again, none of those preferences automatically makes you too picky.

But when you stack them together, you may end up considering very few people.

Then dating can start to feel like:

“Nobody meets my standards.”

The better question may be:

“Which standards are actually connected to the partnership I want?”

This is not about lowering your standards

I want to be very clear about that.

Filtering better does not mean accepting things that do not work for you.

It does not mean ignoring major differences.

It does not mean dating people you already know you do not want.

And it does not mean convincing yourself that attraction should not matter.

This is about making sure the things doing the filtering are the things you truly want to use to make that decision.

You may actually need stronger standards in some areas and more flexibility in others.

For example:

Maybe job title matters less, but financial responsibility matters more.

Maybe sharing every hobby matters less, but having enough time for a relationship matters more.

Maybe living 20 minutes farther away matters less, but having similar goals for the future matters more.

Maybe having the perfect profile matters less, but being able to hold a thoughtful conversation matters more.

That is not lowering your standards.

That is getting clearer about them.

Ask what the filter is trying to tell you

Sometimes a filter has a good reason behind it.

If you say:

“I will not date someone who lives more than 20 miles away,”

ask yourself why.

Maybe you know you are not willing to build a relationship that requires a lot of driving.

That may be completely reasonable.

But maybe 20 miles became your rule because you had one frustrating experience dating someone who lived far away.

Those are different reasons.

Try doing this with some of your strongest filters.

Ask:

What do I believe this filter protects me from?

Or:

What do I believe this filter guarantees me?

You may find that some filters are doing an important job.

You may also find that some are trying to guarantee something they cannot actually guarantee.

A college degree does not guarantee intelligence.

A high-paying career does not guarantee responsibility.

Having the same hobbies does not guarantee compatibility.

Great chemistry does not guarantee partnership.

Those things may still matter to you.

Just be clear about what they actually tell you and what they do not.

Look at who never gets considered

If Filtering is where your dating process gets stuck, one of the best places to look is not at the people you dated.

Look at the people you didn’t date.

Who gets ruled out quickly?

What reasons come up again and again?

Are those reasons connected to the kind of partnership you want?

Or are some of them connected to the image of the person you thought you would build it with?

That can be an uncomfortable question.

It can also be a useful one.

Because the goal is not to consider more people just for the sake of having more dates.

The goal is to make sure potentially good partners are not being removed for reasons that have very little to do with whether the two of you could actually build something healthy together.

Try sorting your list

Take the things you are looking for and put them into three groups:

I need this.

I strongly prefer this.

This would be nice.

Then look at the first group carefully.

Ask yourself:

Can I explain how each one connects to the partnership I want to build?

If the answer is yes, great.

If you cannot explain why something matters beyond:

“I’ve always wanted that,”

it may belong in a different group.

You do not have to remove it.

You just may not want it deciding who gets through the door.

The goal is not to find someone who checks every box

The goal is to find someone with whom you can build the kind of partnership you actually want.

Those are not always the same thing.

A checklist can tell you whether someone matches your picture.

A dating process should help you learn whether they match your life.

And sometimes that starts by becoming a little clearer about who you are willing to consider in the first place.

Where does your dating process get stuck?

Filtering is one of seven places dating can get harder than it needs to be.

You may be meeting plenty of people but ruling them out too quickly.

Or your issue may be somewhere else entirely.

The more clearly you can see where your process is getting stuck, the easier it becomes to work on the part that can actually change.


Maria Lynette Olive

Maria Lynette Olive

Maria Lynette Olive is a dating and relationship coach who helps men and women identify their dating patterns, build self-awareness, and develop the skills needed for a healthy, lasting partnership. Her work focuses on clarity, intentional dating, and emotional maturity.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog