Black and gold graphic that reads, “I don’t know if this is a red flag or if I’m making too much of it,” with the label “Interpretation” from the Where Dating Gets Stuck series.

I Don’t Know If This Is a Red Flag or If I’m Making Too Much of It

September 10, 2025•8 min read

I Don’t Know If This Is a Red Flag or If I’m Making Too Much of It

They took longer than usual to text back.

They canceled a date.

They seemed quieter than normal.

They said something that rubbed you the wrong way.

They were very interested at first, and now something feels different.

Or maybe the opposite happened.

They are texting constantly.

Talking about the future.

Telling you how different you are from everyone else.

Making you feel very wanted.

And now you are trying to figure out:

What does this mean?

Is it a red flag?

Is it nothing?

Am I ignoring something important?

Am I making too much of it?

This is where dating can get hard.

Because seeing behavior is one thing.

Knowing what that behavior actually tells you is another.

Interpretation is the meaning you give the information

Screening helps you gather information.

Interpretation is what happens next.

You notice something.

Then your brain immediately starts trying to explain it.

They have not texted today.

Maybe they are losing interest.

They changed the plans.

Maybe I am not a priority.

They seem nervous.

Maybe they are hiding something.

They are texting me all day.

They must really like me.

They are talking about our future.

They must be serious about me.

Maybe.

But maybe not.

The behavior is real.

The meaning you give the behavior may still be a guess.

That is the part we want to slow down.

Start with: What do I actually know?

One of the most useful things you can do in dating is separate what happened from what you think it means.

For example:

What happened: They took eight hours to answer my text.

What I decided it meant: They are losing interest.

Those are not the same thing.

Or:

What happened: They told me they have never felt this way before.

What I decided it meant: This relationship is becoming serious.

Again, those are not the same thing.

The first part is information.

The second part is your interpretation of the information.

Sometimes your interpretation will turn out to be right.

Sometimes it will not.

So before you build a whole story around one behavior, ask:

What do I know?

What do I not know yet?

That little pause can save you from making a lot of decisions based on guesses.

One behavior rarely tells the whole story

Imagine someone cancels a date at the last minute.

What does that mean?

It could mean they are unreliable.

It could mean something unexpected happened.

It could mean they are losing interest.

It could mean they are terrible at planning.

It could mean absolutely nothing about the future of the relationship.

One canceled date does not automatically tell you which answer is true.

So you need more information.

Did they explain what happened?

Did they apologize?

Did they make another plan?

Does this happen often?

Do they regularly leave you hanging?

Is this unusual for them?

Now you have more to work with.

The point is not to explain away behavior.

The point is to interpret it using enough information.

Look for patterns, not just moments

A single moment can matter.

But patterns usually tell you more.

Someone being late once is different from someone who is regularly late and does not seem concerned about your time.

Someone becoming quiet after a hard day is different from someone shutting you out every time something becomes uncomfortable.

Someone forgetting one thing you told them is different from someone who rarely seems interested in learning about you.

Someone saying something hurtful once and taking responsibility for it is different from someone repeatedly hurting you and then telling you that you are too sensitive.

Patterns give behavior context.

That does not mean you need to wait months before taking something seriously.

It means you want to understand what kind of evidence you actually have.

Positive behavior needs interpretation too

We tend to talk about interpretation when something feels wrong.

But it matters just as much when something feels really good.

They text every morning.

And?

They plan great dates.

And?

They tell you how beautiful you are.

And?

They say they have never connected with someone this quickly.

And?

None of those things are bad.

Enjoy them.

But do not ask those behaviors to prove more than they actually prove.

Someone can be attentive and still not be ready for partnership.

Someone can plan wonderful dates and still have goals that do not fit yours.

Someone can feel intense attraction and still not know you very well.

Someone can be excited about you and still not have the skills or habits needed to build a healthy relationship.

Early positives are information.

They are just not the whole answer.

Feelings can tell you something without telling you everything

You may feel anxious around someone.

That matters.

You may feel safe.

That matters too.

You may feel excited.

Calm.

Confused.

Wanted.

Unsure.

Your feelings can help you notice that something is happening inside you.

But feelings do not automatically tell you what is happening inside the other person.

Feeling nervous does not prove someone is unsafe.

Feeling calm does not prove someone is a great partner.

Feeling intense chemistry does not prove you are compatible.

Feeling bored does not automatically mean the connection is wrong.

Your feelings deserve attention.

They just need to be considered alongside the evidence.

Be careful with labels

Dating language is full of labels.

Red flag.

Green flag.

Avoidant.

Narcissist.

Love bombing.

Emotionally unavailable.

Toxic.

Sometimes a label helps people describe a real pattern.

But sometimes the label becomes the conclusion before we have understood what actually happened.

Instead of starting with:

“Is this a red flag?”

Try starting with:

“What behavior am I actually seeing?”

Then get more specific.

What happened?

How often?

Under what circumstances?

What happened after?

Did they take responsibility?

Did the behavior change?

Does it fit with other things I have seen?

Now you are working with information instead of only a label.

Explanations are not the same as evidence

This can go in both directions.

Sometimes we see behavior we do not like and immediately explain it away.

“They are just busy.”

“They have been through a lot.”

“They are scared because they really like me.”

“They have never had a healthy relationship before.”

Maybe.

But an explanation does not erase the behavior.

On the other hand, sometimes we assume the worst.

“They did that because they do not respect me.”

“They are pulling away.”

“They are playing games.”

“They are trying to control me.”

Maybe.

But that is still an explanation unless you have enough information to support it.

A useful dating process leaves room for curiosity without ignoring what is right in front of you.

You can say:

“I do not know why this is happening yet, but I can still pay attention to the fact that it is happening.”

That is a very different way to date.

Ask questions before you fill in the blanks

Sometimes the easiest way to understand behavior is to ask.

Not accuse.

Not interrogate.

Ask.

“You seemed quieter last night. Was something going on?”

“When our plans changed at the last minute, I wasn't sure what happened. Can you tell me?”

“You have mentioned wanting a relationship, but I am noticing that we rarely make plans ahead of time. How are you thinking about what you want right now?”

The goal is not to get the perfect answer.

The goal is to gather more information.

Then you can also watch whether the answer matches what happens next.

Someone’s words can explain their behavior, but what they do next helps you see whether that explanation holds up.

The question is not always, “Is this good or bad?”

Sometimes we rush to sort everything into two piles.

Green flag.

Red flag.

Good.

Bad.

Keep going.

Run.

But a lot of dating information needs more thought than that.

Maybe the better questions are:

What does this behavior tell me so far?

What else would I need to know?

Is this a one-time event or part of a pattern?

Does what they are saying match what I am seeing?

What am I assuming that I do not actually know yet?

Those questions give you room to stay curious without becoming careless.

Interpretation should help you get closer to the truth

The goal is not to think positively about everyone.

It is not to give endless chances.

And it is not to become suspicious of every little thing.

The goal is to understand the information in front of you as clearly as you can.

Sometimes that information will become more concerning.

Sometimes it will make perfect sense once you know more.

Sometimes what looked wonderful at first will mean less than you thought.

And sometimes something you almost rejected will turn out to be completely understandable.

Interpretation is not about talking yourself into or out of someone.

It is about asking:

What does the evidence actually support?

Because dating gets much harder when we treat every feeling like proof, every explanation like fact, or every single behavior like the whole story.

You do not need to know what everything means immediately.

Sometimes the most accurate answer is simply:

“I don't know yet. I need more information.”

And that is still clarity.

Where does your dating process get stuck?

Maybe you are meeting enough people.

Maybe your filters make sense.

Maybe you are asking good questions and paying attention.

But once you get the information, you struggle to know what to make of it.

That may mean Interpretation is where your process gets stuck.

The goal is not to become better at spotting red flags.

It is to become better at understanding what the information in front of you actually tells you, and what it does not.


Maria Lynette Olive

Maria Lynette Olive

Maria Lynette Olive is a dating and relationship coach who helps men and women identify their dating patterns, build self-awareness, and develop the skills needed for a healthy, lasting partnership. Her work focuses on clarity, intentional dating, and emotional maturity.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog